What Diamond Buyers Ask on Reddit: Antique Cut Share Up 79 Percent in 93,149 Threads
We compared January to September 2026 with the same months of 2025 across five subreddits. Three shifts held up to testing. Three common worries did not clearly move. Every number here is a share of threads, not sales, and the limits sit beside the findings.
Draco Diamond sells lab grown diamonds and ran this study. AI models coded the threads in two independent passes; no person has coded them. Thread volume fell 28.5 percent and removed post bodies doubled, both unexplained. These are shares of threads, not sales, and Reddit is not representative of buyers.

Antique style cuts rose 79 percent as a share of threads, in all five subreddits
Antique style cuts went from 2.83 percent of visible threads in January to September 2025 to 5.06 percent in the same months of 2026. That is a rise of 79 percent, with a range of 58 to 102 percent.
The group covers old mine, old European, antique cushion, Portuguese, Dutch, criss cut, lozenge, French and step cuts. A thread counted only when the poster's own stone, ring or search was one of these.1
This is the strongest result in the study. AI readers checked 120 sampled matches, and 95 percent met the definition, with a range of 83.8 to 98.5 percent. So the word matching is rarely fooled here.
Antique style cuts, share of visible threads by month
Pattern matches per 1,000 visible threads, before precision adjustment. Share of threads, not sales.
Source: Draco Diamond study results, monthly_shares.tsv. The 18 days of October 2026 are left out as a partial month.
The share did not rise in a straight line. It peaked at about 64 raw matches per 1,000 visible threads in June and July 2026, then eased to about 54 and 56 in August and September.1
Do not read that as a reversal yet. Titles alone show the same shape, from about 26 per 1,000 in June and July to about 21 in August and September, but the monthly counts are small. The first 18 days of October came in at 47, on a partial month of 1,186 threads.
Antique style share, 2026 against 2025, by subreddit
Ratio of raw match share, January to September 2026 over January to September 2025. Above 1.00 means a higher share. The panel figure before precision adjustment is 1.82.
Source: Draco Diamond study results, by_subreddit.tsv.
All five subreddits moved the same way. The ratios run from 1.41 on r/Moissanite to 2.30 on r/Diamonds. That matters, because the mix shifted: r/LabDiamonds grew from 2.3 to 6.3 percent of panel threads. Holding subreddit weights fixed still gives 1.79.
Raw counts tell the same story with less force. Matches on title and visible body went from 1,441 to 1,538, a rise of about 7 percent, while the visible base shrank by 41.5 percent. Much of the share rise depends on that smaller base, which is why the titles only count matters.
Not every antique thread is a question. Of 114 threads coded as a yes, 80 were asking or deciding and 34 were showing a stone with no question. That mix barely changed, at 33 and 15 in 2025 and 32 and 15 in 2026.
So this measures how often people talk about these cuts. It does not measure how many they buy. The show and tell flair rose from 20.6 to 22.9 percent of panel threads, which could add a little to any topic people photograph.

Bow tie worry nearly doubled, though the range runs from 1.46 to 2.67 times
Threads where a poster asks or worries about a bow tie went from 1.11 percent of visible threads to 2.20 percent. The central ratio is 1.99, and the range of 1.50 to 2.67 times is wide.
A bow tie is a dark band across the middle of a stone, typically seen in rounded fancy shapes such as ovals, pears and marquises.3 A thread about clothing or a single word in a list of specs did not count.
Bow tie worry, share of visible threads by quarter
Precision adjusted threads per 1,000 visible threads. Q4 2025 sits outside both comparison periods and uses its own smaller precision sample of 20 rows, so read its step with care.
Source: Draco Diamond study results, quarterly_shares.tsv. Partial Q4 2026 left out.
The word bow tie is less reliable than the antique terms. AI readers accepted 69.1 percent of sampled matches. Precision was 62 percent in the 2025 sample and 74 percent in the 2026 sample, each from 50 rows.
That gap flatters the headline. Before precision adjustment the ratio is 1.67. The four checks give 1.87 on titles only, 1.60 with fixed subreddit weights, 2.22 without r/labdiamond and 1.68 with duplicates removed. All agree on direction, but about double sits at the upper part of them.
Raw counts are weaker still. Matches on title and visible body fell slightly, from 873 to 851, while the base shrank. Titles alone, which include removed posts, rose from 329 to 440.
All five subreddits moved up, but not equally. r/Diamonds shows 2.30 and r/LabDiamonds 1.94, while r/labdiamond shows 1.21 and r/Moissanite 1.07.1 The honest reading is a real rise of uncertain size.

Tariff and duty threads spiked in Q2 2025, then fell
Threads about tariffs, duty, customs charges or brokerage on a jewellery purchase jumped in the second quarter of 2025. They then settled lower. This is the one clear fall among the 12 topics audited.
Tariff and duty threads, share of visible threads by quarter
Precision adjusted threads per 1,000 visible threads. The months of the spike are inside the 2025 comparison period.
Source: Draco Diamond study results, quarterly_shares.tsv. Partial Q4 2026 left out.
The adjusted share went from 2.26 per 1,000 visible threads in Q1 2025 to 9.03 in Q2 2025, and stood at 2.98 by Q3 2026. April 2025 alone holds 128 raw matches out of 5,266 visible threads.1
Across the two comparison periods the ratio is 0.65, with a range of 0.46 to 0.91. That is a fall of about 35 percent. All five subreddits fell, with raw ratios from 0.34 to 0.77.
Read the size with care, because the spike itself sits inside the 2025 period. A comparison that starts high will show a fall. What the chart supports is simple: the talk peaked in spring 2025 and has not returned to that level.
We did not test why. Timing alone does not prove a cause, so this study makes no claim about any policy or any change in charges. Coders could not tell which country's rules applied in 36 of 83 threads coded as a yes.
Did regret, price anxiety or seller trust change?
We found no clear change in any of the three. Each range includes 1.00, the point of no change, so the study cannot tell these apart from flat. Flat here means no change detected, and it does not mean proven steady.
| Topic | Share per 1,000, 2025 to 2026 | Precision | Ratio and range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regret | 8.93 to 9.35 | 85.7% | 1.05 (0.84 to 1.30) |
| Price anxiety | 21.50 to 17.96 | 68.5% | 0.84 (0.62 to 1.13) |
| Seller trust | 9.66 to 9.72 | 45.4% | 1.01 (0.64 to 1.60) |
Regret shows a ratio of 1.05, price anxiety 0.84 and seller trust 1.01.1
The ranges are wide, particularly for seller trust. Word matching there is only 45.4 percent precise, because words such as legit and reputable appear in many unrelated threads. A smaller change could be hiding inside any of them.
Where regret appeared, the most common reason coded was the shape or setting of the ring, at 41 of 102 threads. These rows come from people posting about a ring, in a sample of 120 rows, so they are a description and not a rate.
"Antique style cuts went from 2.83 to 5.06 percent of visible threads, the same nine months a year apart."
Draco Diamond Reddit study, January to September 2026 against 2025
Two other tests also failed. Word patterns for lab against natural and for moissanite against diamond were only about 36 percent precise, so we report no trend from them. We also tested whether Canadian posters focus more on cost than American posters. The difference did not hold up, and we do not claim it.
The sample is also too small to support any claim about regret over lab against natural diamonds. We make no such claim, and readers should treat with suspicion any seller who draws one from data like this, including us.
Too big outnumbers too small, but the size trend is too fragile to claim
Among sampled threads where the poster worried about the size of a stone or ring, 74 percent worried it was too big. The range is 63 to 83 percent, from 52 of 70 threads coded as a yes.
The split was similar across periods: 26 of 35 in the 2025 sample, 19 of 24 in the 2026 sample, and 7 of 11 in the other months. Those small counts are why the range is wide.1
Two cautions apply. The word list could favour one side, since it cannot catch every way of saying a stone looks small. A random check of threads the patterns missed also found 4 of 200 that were size worries, so this topic has more hidden threads than most.
Whether size worry as a whole is rising or falling is a separate question, and we do not answer it. Precision in the sample fell between periods, and three of five subreddits moved one way while two moved the other. It failed our test, so we claim no trend.

For buyers with this question, our guide to whether a diamond is too big covers proportion on the hand. It is a separate piece of advice, and this study does not test it.
What can this study not tell you?
It cannot tell you what people buy, or why anything changed. It measures how often topics appear in text from a self selected group of online enthusiasts, in five communities that lean towards lab grown stones and moissanite.
This is not sales data. For the buying side, other sources count rings. The Knot's 2026 study put lab grown centre stones at 61 percent of rings for US couples married in 2025.4 BriteCo appraisal data put them at 51 percent of newly appraised rings from January to June 2026.5
Volume fell and we cannot say why. Total panel threads fell 28.5 percent, from 57,568 to 41,166. A shrinking base can inflate a share, and this could reflect the communities, moderation or the archive itself.
Removed bodies doubled and we cannot say why. The share of panel threads with a removed post body went from 15.1 to 30.6 percent. On r/labdiamond it went from 9.2 to 38.8 percent, and on r/EngagementRings from 17.9 to 31.9 percent.
Our primary measure leaves removed threads out of both sides. If removed threads differ by topic, the visible base no longer reflects all posts. Only the titles only check covers them, which is why every clear trend had to pass it.
No person coded these threads. AI models read every sampled row. An independent second pass then recoded all 480 headline rows without seeing the first labels, agreeing on 88 to 96 percent of threads per topic. Both passes used AI models of the same kind, so their agreement is not the same as two human coders agreeing.
What the second pass changed. Antique cuts: up 86 percent, range 63 to 114. Bow tie: 1.85 times, range 1.46 to 2.38. Tariffs: the Q2 2025 spike held at 9.3 per 1,000 threads. Size: 81 percent too big, range 71 to 89. Every headline held.
A random 40 row sample across the four headline topics is set aside for a person to confirm. Until that is done, treat the precision figures as provisional.
Topics were picked after looking. We chose 12 topics after scanning 89 existing topics, plus some named in advance. Choosing the biggest movers after seeing them can overstate their size, so real rises may be smaller than shown.
Draco has an interest. Draco Diamond sells lab grown diamonds. Agents working for Draco wrote the topic list and the codebook, with no outside review. Draco says it leads through transparency, so the limits sit here beside the numbers.
Other gaps. We used post text only and no comments. The files hold no author data, so repeat posters and coordinated accounts cannot be detected. Estimates are floors, because the recall check was small and rare topics cannot be told apart from zero.
How can a reporter check these numbers?
Start with the arithmetic, since most of it can be redone by hand from the counts on this page. Then test the wording on your own pull from the public archive, and ask us for the rest.
For antique style cuts in 2026, multiply 1,538 matches by the sampled precision of 0.94 and divide by the visible base of 28,578. The result is 50.59 per 1,000.
Do the same for 2025: 1,441 matches times 0.96 over 48,859 gives 28.31 per 1,000. Then 50.59 over 28.31 gives 1.79, which is the 79 percent rise.
Pull the five subreddits for the same months from Arctic Shift and run the words in the table below. The archive may have changed since our pull on October 18, 2026, so expect small differences.
Write to info@dracodiamond.com for the aggregate results tables, the codebook and the analysis script. These hold no usernames and no Reddit text.
Thread level samples stay internal because a thread ID leads to a public post and its author. A reporter who needs to audit the coding can do so under agreement.
An independent second pass recoded all 480 headline sample rows blind. Ask for the agreement table and every disagreement.
Reddit usernames and Reddit text do not appear in this article or in the results tables. We paraphrase topics and quote no posts. Nothing here names or ranks a retailer.
Methods sheet: every definition, denominator and range in one place
This section is written to be lifted out and checked on its own. The Reddit study uses post titles and bodies collected on October 18, 2026 from the Arctic Shift archive, in five fully collected subreddits.
Source. The collection held 180,351 unique threads from January 1, 2025 to October 18, 2026.2 The files hold no usernames and no comments. The panel is r/EngagementRings, r/labdiamond, r/LabDiamonds, r/Diamonds and r/Moissanite.
Exclusions. r/Jewelry was left out because most of it is unrelated to these questions. Three other communities were left out because they were keyword pulls, which have no valid denominator.
| Period | Months | All panel threads | Visible base |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | January to September 2025 | 57,568 | 48,859 |
| B | January to September 2026 | 41,166 | 28,578 |
| Other | October to December 2025, October 1 to 18 2026 | 20,220 | 15,712 |
| Total | All months | 118,954 | 93,149 |
Comparison. We compare the same nine months in each year, which controls for season and drops the partial October. Monthly denominators and quarterly shares are in the results tables.
Matching. Each topic has a deliberately broad word pattern run on the title and visible body. Broad patterns catch more threads and more mistakes, so precision was measured directly.
| Topic | Words matched in title or body | Counted as yes |
|---|---|---|
| Antique style cuts | old mine, old European, OMC, OEC, antique cut, cushion, oval, style, elongated, stone, diamond or looking, Portuguese cut or oval, Dutch marquise or step, step cut, criss cut, lozenge, French cut | The poster's own stone, ring or search is that style |
| Bow tie worry | bow tie, bowtie | The poster asks or worries about a bow tie on a stone they own or are considering |
| Tariff and duty | customs, duty, duties, tariff, import fee, import tax, brokerage, with custom design and heavy duty senses excluded | The poster asks about or reports a charge on a jewellery purchase |
| Size worry | too small, too big and close wordings, go bigger, gaudy, too flashy | The poster worries whether a stone or ring is too small or too big, and finger fit does not count |
Sampling. For each of 12 topics we drew 120 random matches, with 50 from each comparison period and 20 from the other months, using a fixed seed of 20261104. A check on 200 threads matching no pattern gave a rough view of what the patterns miss.
Coding. Four separate Claude AI model agents labelled each row yes, no or unclear against a written codebook. They saw the title and a 240 character excerpt, with no dates and no target rates. Unclear counts as no. Scripted labelling was prohibited.
Agreement. A lead agent recoded 25 rows from each of 13 sets, 325 rows in all, and agreed on 314. Kappa ran from 0.75 to 1.00 for each set, except antique cuts, where it is 0 because almost every row is a yes. The thirteenth set covers named seller mentions, used only for internal checks and not reported.
Estimates. Adjusted threads are matches times sampled precision, summed by period. Adjusted share divides that by the visible base. Precision ranges are 95 percent Wilson intervals. Trend ranges come from 20,000 seeded simulation draws, and they reflect sampling only.
Verdicts. A clear trend needs a range that excludes 1.00, the same direction in all four checks, and at least four of five subreddits moving the same way. A range that excludes 1.00 with a failed check is fragile. Anything else is no clear change.
| Topic | Precision (range) | Reading | Ratio and range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Antique style cuts | 95.0% (83.8 to 98.5) | Clear, claimed | 1.79 (1.58 to 2.02) |
| Bow tie worry | 69.1% (54.0 to 80.7) | Clear, claimed | 1.99 (1.50 to 2.67) |
| Tariff and duty | 66.9% (51.8 to 78.6) | Clear, claimed | 0.65 (0.46 to 0.91) |
| Regret | 85.7% (72.3 to 93.2) | No clear change | 1.05 (0.84 to 1.30) |
| Price anxiety | 68.5% (53.2 to 80.1) | No clear change | 0.84 (0.62 to 1.13) |
| Seller trust | 45.4% (31.4 to 59.9) | No clear change | 1.01 (0.64 to 1.60) |
| Resale and value worry | 45.3% (31.5 to 59.8) | No clear change | 0.83 (0.48 to 1.37) |
| Poster in Canada | 71.2% (56.4 to 82.7) | No clear change | 1.02 (0.77 to 1.35) |
| Poster in the US | 50.0% (35.6 to 64.4) | No clear change | 0.66 (0.42 to 1.00) |
| Moissanite against diamond | 35.9% (23.3 to 50.8) | Low precision, not claimed | 1.03 (0.58 to 1.82) |
| Lab against natural | 35.8% (23.5 to 50.7) | Low precision, not claimed | 1.11 (0.65 to 1.92) |
| Size worry | 61.4% (46.5 to 74.5) | Fragile, not claimed | 0.57 (0.39 to 0.80) |
| Check | Antique | Bow tie | Tariff |
|---|---|---|---|
| Titles only, all panel threads | 1.97 | 1.87 | 0.51 |
| Fixed subreddit weights | 1.79 | 1.60 | 0.57 |
| Without r/labdiamond | 1.91 | 2.22 | 0.53 |
| Exact duplicates removed | 1.82 | 1.68 | 0.55 |
Composition, 2025 to 2026. r/LabDiamonds rose from 2.3 to 6.3 percent of panel threads, r/EngagementRings fell from 51.3 to 48.1 percent and r/Moissanite fell from 13.0 to 11.3 percent.
Privacy. Thread text was shown to coders with handles, emails, long numbers and links masked, and it was never saved. Saved samples hold only IDs, months, subreddits and codes. Those samples stay internal because an ID can lead to an author.
Contact. Questions and requests for the aggregate tables go to info@dracodiamond.com.
The study, answered
Does this show antique cuts are selling more?
No. It shows a larger share of Reddit threads about them, in five communities. It is not sales data, and Reddit is not representative of buyers.
How big is the antique style rise?
From 2.83 to 5.06 percent of visible threads, January to September 2025 against the same months of 2026. That is up 79 percent, with a range of 58 to 102 percent.
Why trust a study from a company that sells diamonds?
You should check it. Draco Diamond sells lab grown diamonds, and agents working for Draco wrote the topic list and codebook. The counts and the steps to test them are on this page.
Did people read the threads?
Not yet. Claude AI model agents coded every sampled row. A random 40 row sample is set aside for a person to confirm, and the precision figures stay provisional until then.
Why did thread volume fall?
We do not know. Panel threads fell 28.5 percent and removed post bodies doubled from 15.1 to 30.6 percent. Either could affect any trend, so we checked titles on all threads as well.
Does the study say lab grown buyers regret their choice?
No. Regret overall shows no clear change, and the sample is too small to support any claim about lab against natural.
Can I get the data?
Write to info@dracodiamond.com for the aggregate tables, codebook and script. Thread level audits are possible under agreement, because thread IDs lead to public posts and their authors.
References
- Draco Diamond, Draco Diamond Reddit study, methods sheet and results tables, November 4, 2026.
- Arctic Shift, Arctic Shift, Reddit archive and API, accessed 2026-11-04.
- GIA, Gems & Gemology, Fall 2024, Observations of Oval-, Pear-, and Marquise-Shaped Diamonds, 2024.
- IDEX Online, reporting The Knot 2026 Real Weddings Study, More Than 6 of 10 US Engagement Rings are Lab Grown, March 1, 2026.
- INSTORE, reporting the BriteCo Price Index, Report: Lab-Grown Stones Now in Majority of Newly Appraised Engagement Rings, September 3, 2026.
Questions about the methods or the data
The aggregate tables, the codebook and the analysis script are available at info@dracodiamond.com. Garrett McMartin is available for interviews.







